As a seasoned outdoor writer and adventurer with over a decade spent testing gear in the field, I’ve become intimately familiar with the Mystery Ranch lineup. When it comes to durable, thoughtfully designed packs, especially for hunting and backcountry use, Mystery Ranch consistently delivers. Today, we’re diving deep into the Mystery Ranch Metcalf reviews, exploring its features, sizing, and how it stacks up against other popular models like the Backstrap and Guide Light MT Frame. Choosing the right pack is crucial, and I’m here to help you navigate the options, whether you’re looking for a women’s hunting backpack or a versatile daypack.
Before we get into specific models, it’s important to understand what sets Mystery Ranch apart. Founded by Dana Gleason, the company prioritizes load carriage, durability, and a customizable fit. Their signature Guide Frame is renowned for transferring weight to your hips, making even heavy loads feel manageable. This isn’t just marketing hype; I’ve personally carried over 70 pounds in a Mystery Ranch pack for days on end with minimal discomfort. Mystery Ranch focuses on building packs for professionals – guides, hunters, military – and that translates to exceptional quality for all users. They also offer a robust repair program, extending the life of your investment.
The Mystery Ranch Metcalf is a relatively new addition to the Mystery Ranch family, quickly gaining popularity as a versatile, do-it-all pack. It’s designed as a hybrid – capable of handling day hunts, overnight trips, and even longer backcountry excursions. I’ve spent the last season putting the Metcalf through its paces in the Montana backcountry, and here’s what I’ve found.
I found the Metcalf to be exceptionally comfortable, even with a heavy load. The Guide Frame really shines, and the adjustable torso length allowed me to dial in a perfect fit. The Overload Shelf proved invaluable during a recent elk hunt, allowing me to comfortably pack out a quartered elk. The pack’s organization is well-thought-out, with plenty of pockets and compartments to keep my gear accessible. I also appreciate the durability; after several months of hard use, the Metcalf shows minimal wear and tear.
Proper Mystery Ranch sizing is critical for comfort and performance. The Metcalf is available in three sizes:
Measuring your torso length is essential. Have a friend help you measure from your C7 vertebra (the bony bump at the base of your neck) to the iliac crest (the top of your hip bones). Mystery Ranch also offers detailed sizing guides on their website: Mystery Ranch Fit Guide. Don’t hesitate to visit a retailer to try on packs and get professional fitting advice.
The Metcalf is a fantastic pack, but it’s not the right choice for everyone. Here’s how it compares to some other popular Mystery Ranch models:
The Mystery Ranch Backstrap is a minimalist, lightweight pack designed primarily for day hunts. It’s a stripped-down version of the Metcalf, lacking the Overload Shelf and some of the organizational features. The Backstrap is ideal for hunters who prioritize weight savings and don’t anticipate carrying extremely heavy loads. I often recommend the Backstrap for those who are new to hunting or prefer a lighter setup. If you anticipate regularly packing out game, the Metcalf’s Overload Shelf is a significant advantage.
The Mystery Ranch Guide Light MT Frame is another lightweight option, focusing on simplicity and durability. It’s a frameless pack, making it incredibly lightweight, but it sacrifices some of the load-carrying capacity of the Metcalf. The Guide Light is best suited for experienced backcountry travelers who are comfortable with minimalist gear and don’t need to carry exceptionally heavy loads. It’s a great choice for fast-and-light adventures.
The Mystery Ranch Overload is designed for truly massive loads – think multi-day backcountry hunts with heavy gear and game. It features a larger frame and more robust construction than the Metcalf. While incredibly capable, the Overload is overkill for most hunters and backpackers. It’s a specialized pack for those who consistently carry extremely heavy loads.
| Feature | Metcalf | Backstrap | Guide Light MT Frame | Overload |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Weight | ~6.5 lbs | ~3.5 lbs | ~2.2 lbs | ~7.8 lbs |
| Load Capacity | Up to 70+ lbs | Up to 50 lbs | Up to 40 lbs | Up to 100+ lbs |
| Overload Shelf | Yes | No | No | Yes |
| Best Use | Versatile Hunting/Backpacking | Day Hunts | Fast & Light Backpacking | Extreme Load Hauling |
Mystery Ranch offers several packs specifically designed for the female anatomy. The women’s hunting backpack options, like the women’s specific versions of the Metcalf and Backstrap, feature shorter torso lengths, narrower shoulder straps, and a contoured hip belt for a more comfortable and secure fit. I highly recommend trying on a women’s specific pack if you’re a female hunter or backpacker. A proper fit can make a huge difference in comfort and performance.
Mystery Ranch doesn’t just make packs; they also offer a range of accessories to enhance your backcountry experience. Their Mystery Ranch game bags are incredibly durable and breathable, perfect for keeping meat clean and protected during transport. They also offer rain covers, compression sacks, and other useful accessories. Leave No Trace principles are paramount when packing out game, and proper game bags are essential for responsible backcountry ethics.
The Mystery Ranch Metcalf is a well-designed, versatile pack that’s capable of handling a wide range of backcountry adventures. Its comfortable fit, durable construction, and innovative features like the Overload Shelf make it a standout choice for hunters and backpackers alike. While it may not be the lightest or most minimalist option, its ability to carry heavy loads comfortably and securely makes it a valuable asset in the field. Remember to prioritize proper Mystery Ranch sizing and consider your specific needs when choosing a pack. Investing in a quality pack like the Metcalf is an investment in your comfort, safety, and enjoyment of the outdoors. For more information on pack selection and backcountry preparedness, check out resources from the National Park Service and the USDA Forest Service. And don't forget to read more about choosing the right backpacking tent for your adventures!